Date: April 6, 1999 Spot Rate: 42.70 Time 18:00 (IST)
Today the Indian Rupee lost some ground against the US Dollar,
moving to 42.70 (42.78 at the peak) from 42.45 yesterday. We
almost hear everyone asking, "Is another devaluation on the
cards?" The answer is NO.
Forecast
Over a 1-month time frame the market ought to trade in a range of
42.50 to 43.00. Over a 3-month time, the maximum we would
expect is 43.50.
Some Perspective
The Rupee has not been "devalued" today. It weakened today on
account of inter-bank trading in reaction to a flash on a newswire
service that Jayalalitha would oppose a Trust Motion is Parliament.
The story later proved to be unfounded. So much for the "Amma"
factor. Compared with the major international currencies like the
Yen, Euro and Pound, which fluctuate to the extent of almost 1%
everyday, the Rupee is not volatile at all. Today’s movement has
been just 0.77%, after almost eight months of stability (since mid-
August last year) around 42.50.
Exports Humbug
"The Finance Secretary, Vijay Kelkar, has hinted at Rupee
depreciation to spur exports", reports Business Standard. This is a
recurring phenomenon - politicians and bureaucrats, exporters and
chambers of commerce - calling for a weaker Rupee to kickstart
Exports. We have to wake up to the fact, that the Rupee is not the
magic cure for our dismal export performance. Even after the sharp
fall in the Rupee from near 39.25 in March ’98 to 42.50 by June (a
fall of 8.28%), exports have not grown in 1998-99. We have to
admit that there are other factors governing exports also, such as
the state of the world markets and world trade, the quality of Indian
goods, delivery schedules etc. The much deeper rooted problems are holding
back Indian exports. Calling for a weaker Rupee is just a "quick fix".
The Sensex is a better indicator
As you are aware, the BSE Sensex is a better indicator of the
Rupee’s health than imports or exports and we have long been
bullish on the Sensex. With companies like Infosys listing on the
NASDAQ and Satyam planning an ADR issue and FIIs keen on the
market, there is no threat to the Rupee. Consider this: the Asian
crisis has cooled off, there is some hope of an economic revival on
the horizon, inflation is below 5%, India’s forex reserves are in
excess of $ 31 billion. There is no reason for FIIs to pull money out of
India.
The only black spot on the sun is Amma’s shenanigans. But both
the equity market and the forex markets have learnt to live with
that. What happens if the BJP government falls? A Congress-led
coalition comes to power. Who is going to be the Finance Minister
then? Dr. Manmohan Singh. Is that a reason to sell the Rupee? We
think not.